Insights

Why every candidate in your Applicant Tracking System needs a recorded reason for changing jobs

Every candidate in an Applicant Tracking System has a reason for looking at a new job, even when it is never written down. One person wants more responsibility, another wants a shorter commute, a third is worried about a reorganisation at their current employer. Recruiters usually hear that reason in the first conversation, but it often ends up in a free-text note or only in someone's memory. When the reason for changing jobs is recorded in a fixed place on the profile, the whole team can use it for matching, for client conversations and for judging how firm a candidate really is.

The value differs per segment. Recruitment agencies use the reason to explain to a client why a candidate fits the role beyond the CV. Staffing teams see that availability, hours and travel time often outweigh small differences in pay. Secondment organisations learn why consultants want to move to a different assignment. In executive search the motivation of a senior candidate is often the deciding factor in a long process. In-house recruitment teams use it to see what attracts external candidates and why internal applicants want to move.

Record the reason in a fixed field, not only in notes

Add a field for the main reason for changing jobs to the candidate profile, with a short list of standard options, such as career growth, pay and benefits, travel time or location, working hours, culture or management, job security and type of work. Allow a second reason and a short explanation in the candidate's own words. Keep the list short and shared, in the same way as a shared skills and tag list, so that recruiters choose the same option for the same situation. A free-text note can add detail, but it cannot be filtered or compared.

Ask the question at the right moment

The best moment is the first real conversation, when you also discuss the salary expectation, the notice period and the preferred contract type and hours. Ask an open question first and choose the standard option afterwards, so you do not put words in the candidate's mouth. If the reason was already captured with screening questions on the application form, confirm it in the conversation and correct it where needed.

Use the reason when matching and submitting

A recorded reason makes matching more precise. A candidate who leaves because of a long commute should not be proposed for a role with the same travel time, even if the skills fit, so combine the reason with the recorded work location and travel radius. Compare the reason with the structured brief of the vacancy: if the role offers exactly what the candidate is missing today, say so in the submission. Clients value an explanation of why a candidate wants this role, not only why they can do it.

Spot risk before the offer stage

The reason also says something about how firm a candidate is. Someone who mainly wants more pay is more likely to accept a counter-offer from the current employer, so link the reason to the counter-offer check at the offer stage. When the reason changes during the process, for example because the current employer has solved the problem, record the new reason and the date. That makes it easier to understand later why a candidate withdrew.

Keep it current and respect privacy

A reason for changing jobs is a snapshot. When you contact a candidate again months later, ask whether the reason still applies and update it, as part of keeping dormant profiles up to date. Record only what is relevant for the work and avoid personal or sensitive details about health, family situation or conflicts. Share the reason with a client only in neutral, professional wording and only with the candidate's agreement, and apply the same retention period as for the rest of the profile.

Look at the reasons across all candidates

Once reasons are recorded consistently, the Applicant Tracking System can show patterns. Which reasons are most common among candidates who are placed? Do candidates who leave because of growth accept offers more often than candidates who leave because of pay? Which reasons appear most among candidates who drop out? Use your own recorded data for this and look at it per segment and per type of role in your monthly recruitment report, rather than relying on general assumptions.

A practical start

  • Add a main reason and an optional second reason to the candidate profile
  • Agree on a short shared list of standard reasons and what each one means
  • Ask the open question in the first conversation and choose the option afterwards
  • Mention the reason in client submissions in neutral wording, with the candidate's agreement
  • Check the reason again before the offer stage and when you contact a candidate later
  • Review placements and drop-outs by reason in your monthly report

Know why, not only who

Skills and experience tell you whether a candidate can do the job. The reason for changing jobs tells you whether this job is the right next step for them. When that reason is recorded in a fixed place in your Applicant Tracking System, matching becomes more precise, submissions become stronger and fewer processes fail at the last moment. Make it a regular point in your weekly pipeline review for candidates who are close to an offer.